Jack Sheridan, the bar owner at the centre of Netflix’s Virgin River, is a former Marine with five combat deployments behind him, and the show treats that history as the source of his appeal. Mel Monroe, a widowed nurse practitioner and midwife, moves to his remote town to rebuild her life, and the romance that follows depends on Jack being settled and already past the restless years that younger leads are still working through. Season 6 logged about 213 million viewing hours during its four weeks in the Netflix global top 10, so the formula still has a very large audience.
The Stability of the Older Lead
The older man in a romantic drama usually comes with a fixed address and an established trade. Jack owns the bar that the whole town uses. Luke Danes in Gilmore Girls owns the diner at the social centre of Stars Hollow, and his slow romance with Lorelai Gilmore developed across seven seasons before the 2016 revival brought it to a wedding.
Virgin River is adapted from Robyn Carr’s novels, and the television version kept Jack’s military past at the centre of the character. Season 7 followed with about 175.6 million hours, a lower total that still kept the show in the global top 10 for four weeks. When a Utah television station reported on favourite TV couples by state, Luke and Lorelai came first in Utah.
The writing in both shows gives these men very little to prove. Their conflicts arrive from outside, through grief or an old relationship, and the man himself is written as the steady figure the heroine keeps returning to. Age is shorthand for that reliability. A character who owns a business and has already made his worst mistakes is easy for an audience to trust within a single episode, and a slow romance needs that trust in place early.
Research on Partner Age Preference
Women in all 45 countries surveyed tended to prefer older men, and men tended to prefer younger women, in a 2020 Psychological Science study that asked 14,399 people what they wanted in a partner. The study replicated work David Buss published in the 1980s, and its authors described the sex differences as robust.
A study of about 4,500 blind dates, published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences in January 2025, measured attraction after real meetings and found that men and women alike were slightly more attracted to younger potential partners. The daters’ own stated upper age limits played almost no part in whom they liked. The men participating in the study were about 3.5 years older than the women on average.
In real life, dating an older guy raises practical questions about children and timing, and most scripts skip them because the drama needs the age difference to look resolved from the first episode.
Later-Life Romance in British Drama
Last Tango in Halifax, which began on BBC One in November 2012, moved the mature lead much further up the age range. Derek Jacobi and Anne Reid played Alan and Celia, two widowed people in their seventies who reconnect on Facebook roughly 60 years after a teenage attraction they never acted on.
They marry in the second series, first quietly with two passers-by as witnesses and then again on Christmas Eve with their families present. Alan is written as patient and openly delighted to have a second chance, and the scripts treat his age as part of the courtship.
The opening episode drew about 6.2 million viewers, a 25.6% share of the audience in its slot, and an episode in the second series reached 7.6 million. Those figures came from a romance between two pensioners.
Sally Wainwright, who created and wrote the series, based it on her mother, Dorothy, who reconnected with a childhood friend through Friends Reunited and married him within six months.
The series ran on BBC One until March 2020, and much of its later material followed Alan and Celia through the ordinary friction of a marriage begun late, including disputes involving their adult daughters.
An Australian Period Example
Australian television produced its own version in A Place to Call Home, which premiered on the Seven Network in April 2013. Marta Dusseldorp played Sarah Adams, a nurse returning to rural New South Wales after 20 years abroad, and Brett Climo played George Bligh, a widower who heads the Ash Park estate.
The romance develops alongside questions of class and family secrets, and George’s appeal comes from his authority and his willingness to revise his own judgements. The show is set around the fictional town of Inverness, with Sydney as a third location, and much of its tension comes from the standing of the Bligh family in the district.
Seven declined to renew the series after its second season in 2014. Foxtel then revived A Place to Call Home for its SoHo channel, and the drama continued until its final episode in October 2018, six seasons in total.
The Distance Between Screen Couples and Census Data
The real figures are more modest than the screen version. Pew Research Center’s 2024 analysis of US Census Bureau data found that husbands and wives were about 2.2 years apart on average in 2022, down from 4.9 years in 1880.
About half of opposite-sex marriages were between spouses of roughly the same age, and in about 40% the husband was three or more years older. Marriages in which the wife was three or more years older made up 10%, slightly below a peak of 11% in 2000.
Remarriage widens the difference. Pew found that husbands in their first marriage were much more likely than remarried husbands to be close in age to their wives, 56% against 32%.
Last Tango in Halifax and A Place to Call Home both build their older men around widowhood and the possibility of a second marriage, which is the group where larger gaps are more common in the census data.
The Screenwriting Appeal of a Finished Backstory
An older man gives a romance writer a finished backstory, and that saves the screen time a younger character would spend growing up. The audience can trust him early, so the plot can spend its episodes on grief and small-town trouble.
That practical reason helps explain the trope’s staying power better than any broad claim about what women want, especially since the 2025 blind-date study found a slight pull toward younger partners in both sexes.
Alan Buttershaw and Jack Sheridan belong to different generations, yet both serve the same function in the story, which is to stay put while the heroine makes up her mind. Television keeps returning to the older lead partly because his established history makes him efficient to write, and viewers keep returning because a steady character is easy company at the end of a long day.

